Pilot planning
Scoring Three Pilot Ideas Side by Side Before You Choose
A pilot needs one goal. If your team has several good ones, a plain scorecard turns a long debate into a short, friendly decision.
To choose between several pilot ideas, list each one in a table, score it on five plain criteria, and pick the highest scorer as your first small project. Keep the others on a "next" list. The Japan-side partnership window recommends starting small and time-limited, with one goal per pilot, so the scorecard's job is to find the single idea that is easiest to start and most useful to learn from.
Teams often arrive with more than one wish. A label wants a co-written song and a catalog introduction. A school wants a guest class and a student video exchange. A festival organizer wants a shared stage and an online showcase. All of these are reasonable, and the scorecard keeps them from competing for attention in the same month.
What a pilot looks like here
A pilot is a short, bounded project with a partner, built to test how well you work together before anything larger begins. The examples in the partnership process are deliberately modest: one co-written song, one online class, or one joint showcase. A pilot may also be an online workshop or a limited-time online release. Before the start, the two sides settle four things: the goal, each side's role, the deadline, and how they will look back afterwards.
Because a pilot is small, it is easy to say yes to. The scorecard keeps it that way. Each idea is measured against how small, clear and finishable it is, not against how impressive it sounds.
The five criteria
Give each idea a score from 1 to 5 on every row, where 5 is the best. The five rows below suit most music teams, schools and event organizers.
| Criterion | Question to ask | A 5 looks like |
|---|---|---|
| One clear goal | Can we state the goal in one sentence? | "Write and demo one song together." |
| Small and time-limited | Can it start and finish in a short, fixed period? | A date range everyone can see on one calendar |
| Easy roles | Is it obvious who does what on each side? | One lead per side and a short role sheet |
| Measurable result | Will we be able to tell whether it worked? | Three success points, agreed before the start |
| Room to grow | If it goes well, is the next step natural? | A clear follow-up such as a second song or a second class |
Add the five scores for each idea. A total near the top of the range is a strong first pilot. If two ideas tie, look at the first row, because one clear goal is what the whole structure rests on.
A worked example with three ideas
Here is how a small music school might fill in the table for three ideas it wants to try with a partner in Japan. The scores are illustrative, to show the method.
| Idea | Goal | Small | Roles | Result | Growth | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| One online vocal class | 5 | 5 | 4 | 4 | 5 | 23 |
| Student video exchange | 4 | 4 | 3 | 3 | 4 | 18 |
| Visiting teacher week | 3 | 2 | 3 | 3 | 4 | 15 |
The online class wins because it is the easiest to describe, schedule and review, and it points naturally towards a regular series. The visiting teacher week scores lower for now. It does not disappear: it goes to the "next" list, and the first pilot helps prepare for it by showing how your teams communicate.
Questions that sharpen each row
Scores are only as good as the questions behind them. If a row feels hard to score, use these prompts to make the answer concrete.
| Row | Prompts to try |
|---|---|
| One clear goal | If we only managed this one thing, would we call the pilot a success? Could a new colleague read the goal and understand it? |
| Small and time-limited | What is the last date? What would we drop if the schedule became tight? |
| Easy roles | Who sends the first message? Who approves the final version? Who is the backup if someone is away? |
| Measurable result | What will we be able to point to when it ends, such as a file, a recording, a date on the calendar or a set of comments? |
| Room to grow | If this goes well, what would the next small step be, and who would ask for it? |
Spend no more than a few minutes per row. The point is to notice where an idea is vague, and a vague row is usually fixed with one added sentence in the plan.
Scoring with your partner, not for them
Scores from one side only tell half the story. After the first online meeting, share the table with your partner and invite them to score the same ideas. Differences are useful. If you gave the video exchange a 4 for roles and they gave it a 2, that is the conversation to have before anything is signed.
- Score alone first. Each side fills in its own copy without discussing it.
- Compare the totals and the biggest gaps. Gaps of two points or more deserve a short talk.
- Ask what would raise a low score. A role sheet may lift the "roles" row. A shorter date range may lift the "small" row.
- Re-score once. Then choose. A second round of scoring is enough.
The partnership window meets first online, in English or Japanese, and then prepares a written proposal with costs and a payment schedule. Terms, costs, dates and rights are confirmed case by case before agreement, so it helps to arrive at that meeting with your scored shortlist. The proposal can then be compared directly with the goal you chose.
Three success points to set before you start
The scorecard picks the pilot. A short list of success points tells you afterwards whether it worked. The Japan-side guidance on evaluating a small pilot suggests keeping success measures to about three, chosen from areas such as the quality of the work, how smoothly the project ran, how listeners or students reacted, and the cost and time involved.
| Pilot idea | Success point 1 | Success point 2 | Success point 3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| One co-written song | We finished a demo we are proud of | Both teams found the process easy to follow | Listeners responded positively to the demo |
| One online class | Students understood the main lesson | The time-zone arrangement worked for both sides | Students asked to take part again |
| One joint showcase | Every planned item was performed | Roles were clear on the day | Audience feedback was warm |
Write the success points on the same page as the scorecard. When the pilot ends, you will be reviewing exactly what you decided to look for.
Keeping a record for the review
A pilot review goes smoothly when the facts have been noted along the way. The Japan-side guidance suggests keeping track of how many exchanges took place, how much time and money went in, and what problems and successes appeared. A simple running log is enough. Then the review follows a clear order: compare the goal with the result, look back together with your partner, agree on small adjustments, and decide whether to continue, change the shape, or finish. Finishing is a valid outcome, because a clear answer is itself a useful result.
- Keep one shared note for dates, decisions and open questions.
- Record the hours each side spends, even roughly.
- Write down one thing that went well and one thing to adjust after every meeting.
A simple week for scoring and deciding
Your own preparation can fit into one working week, which keeps momentum without rushing anyone.
- Monday: list every idea in one document and write each goal in a single sentence.
- Tuesday: score alone, then compare with one colleague.
- Wednesday: send the shortlist and your goals to the partnership window, with your country, time zone and preferred language.
- Once a date is agreed: hold the first online meeting and score the two finalists together.
- Afterwards: review the written proposal against the success points you set.
Common questions the scorecard answers
What if our favorite idea scores low?
Treat the score as a to-do list. A low "small" score suggests shortening the plan. A low "roles" score suggests naming one lead per side. Revise the idea and score it again.
What if every idea scores high?
Choose the one with the most readable result, then place the others on the next list in the order of their scores. A good first pilot makes the second one easier to design.
Can we change the pilot once it starts?
Small adjustments are welcome, and they belong in your shared note. If a new idea arrives, add it to the next list so the current goal stays clear and finishable.
If you would like help turning a shortlist into a first pilot, the Global Music Partnership window works in English and Japanese. Send your company or school name, country and time zone, your goals, and any existing material, even if the plan is still loose, and the team will help organize it: global-music-partnership.jp.
FAQ
How many ideas should we score?
Two to four is comfortable. More than that usually means the goals are not yet focused, so combine similar ideas first.
Do we need a finished plan before contacting the partnership window?
No. You can send your goals and any existing material, and the team will help organize them.
Who should fill in the scorecard?
The person who will lead the pilot on your side, with one colleague who can check the roles and schedule. Your partner then scores the same list.
Is the scorecard part of the partnership agreement?
It is a planning aid for your own team and your partner. The agreement itself records goals, roles, costs, schedule and rights in writing.