AI and songwriting

One Song, Two Versions: An Experiment With and Without AI

 By the GLOBAL MUSIC PARTNERSHIP editorial team / Supervised by Naoto Tanaka (Tarnar sensei)

Curious about AI in songwriting but not sure where it helps? Make the same short song two ways and let your own ears decide.

The easiest way to learn where AI helps your songwriting is to write one short song twice: once entirely by hand, and once with AI help in the stages you choose. Then listen to both versions side by side, say which parts you prefer and why, and decide what to keep doing by hand. The experiment is small, takes a few sessions, and gives you a personal answer rather than someone else's opinion.

The Japan-side songwriting team works with both approaches. The theme music it wrote for a national television program was made without AI, in both lyrics and music. A song for a community musical was made with AI from the lyrics through to the finish. Its AI songwriting lessons teach both ways of working. That experience points to a calm, practical attitude: use AI where it serves the song, and choose carefully what stays in human hands.

Set up the experiment

Before you begin, agree on the basics with your co-writer. Keep the song short, because a small piece is easier to compare.

DecisionA good starting choice
LengthOne verse and one chorus
ThemeOne sentence, such as "the first morning in a new city"
Lyric languageEnglish, Japanese or both, decided before writing
Target listenerOne real person you can picture
Reference songsThree tracks that capture the mood
Who writes Version AYou and your co-writer, by hand
Who writes Version BThe same pair, with AI at agreed stages

Using the same theme, language and listener for both versions keeps the comparison fair. The only thing that changes is how the song is made.

The stages where AI can take part

A song passes through several stages, and you can decide separately for each one whether to use AI. The Japan-side AI songwriting lessons walk through the same list, asking at each stage how to ask AI for help, what to hand over, and what to decide yourself.

StageBy hand (Version A)With AI (Version B)
LyricsWrite from your own images and notesAsk AI for draft lines, then rewrite them in your own words
Melody and chordsFind the tune at the piano or guitarAsk AI for several melody ideas, then choose one
ArrangementChoose instruments and structure yourselvesAsk AI for arrangement options and pick what suits
RecordingRecord the vocal and parts yourselvesUse AI tools where you want help with parts
Mixing and masteringBalance and finish by earUse AI assistance, then adjust by ear

You do not have to use AI at every stage in Version B. Many writers choose two or three stages, such as lyrics and arrangement, and keep melody and recording in their own hands. The point is to notice the difference at each stage.

Make Version A by hand

Start with the hand-made version, so that your own instincts come first. Write the verse and chorus the way you normally would. Record a simple demo on a phone, with voice and piano or guitar. Save the file with a clear name such as "Song-A-by-hand".

  1. Write the theme and listener at the top of a page.
  2. Draft four to eight lines of verse and chorus.
  3. Find a melody that suits the stress of your words.
  4. Record one clear take.
  5. Write three notes: what you love, what is missing, how long it took.

Make Version B with AI

For the AI-assisted version, treat the AI as a collaborator who offers options. Be specific when you ask. The Japan-side lyric lessons teach how to phrase requests and, importantly, how to turn the words that come back into your own language instead of using them as they are.

Ask clearly

Give the AI the theme, the listener, the language and the mood. Ask for several short options rather than one finished song. Keep every request in a note so you can repeat or adjust it later.

Listen to the options together

Play the options side by side with your co-writer. Choose one and say the reason aloud: "This one sounds closer to the first morning in a new city." The lessons on the Japan side use exactly this listen, choose and explain routine.

Make it yours

Rewrite lyric lines that the AI suggests until they sound like something you would say. Change a word, reorder a line, add a detail only you know. Small edits make a draft personal.

Record Version B

Record the demo in the same way as Version A, with the same singer and the same phone. Save it as "Song-B-with-AI" and write the same three notes.

Keep a request log

While you work on Version B, keep a simple log of what you asked the AI and what came back. It becomes the raw material for your making-of note, and it shows you which kinds of requests give the most useful results.

What you askedWhat came backWhat you keptWhat you changed
Four chorus lines about a first morningThree short optionsThe image in option twoThe last line, rewritten in your own words
Three melody ideas in a gentle moodThree short clipsThe second clip's riseThe ending, played by hand

Compare the two versions

Listen to both versions twice: once straight through, and once while reading your notes. Then fill in a comparison table with your co-writer.

QuestionVersion AVersion B
Which has the stronger first line?
Which chorus is easier to remember?
Which feels more like us?
Which surprised us more?
Which took less time?
Which would we play for a friend?

Look for patterns rather than a winner. Perhaps AI gave you speed in arrangement but your own hands found the better chorus melody. That answer is more useful than a vote for one side.

A fair listening session

Your ears are the judges, so give them the best conditions. A few small habits keep the comparison honest and kind.

  • Blind first. Ask a third person to play the two files in a random order, without saying which is which. Note your first reactions before the labels are revealed.
  • Same volume. Match the loudness of the two files so the louder one does not seem better.
  • Short breaks. Rest for a minute between files so the second does not blur into the first.
  • Praise first. Name one thing you like in each version before you say what you would change.
  • Come back tomorrow. Listen again the next day. Fresh ears often confirm or change the first impression.

A sample schedule across four sessions

SessionWorkOutput
1Agree theme, language, listener and reference songs; write Version A lyricsA page of lyrics and notes
2Finish and record Version A"Song-A-by-hand" demo and three notes
3Make Version B with AI at the agreed stages"Song-B-with-AI" demo and three notes
4Blind listening, comparison table, working-method statementA one-page summary to share with your partner

Turn the result into a working method

With the table filled in, write a short statement of how you want to work from now on. For instance: "We write lyrics and melody ourselves, ask AI for arrangement options, and always record who did what." Share it with your partner in Japan so that expectations are clear on both sides.

  • Note which stages you keep by hand.
  • Note which stages you ask AI to support.
  • Keep a short making-of note for every song, listing how each part was made.
  • Agree on credits and rights in writing before the project begins, as with any co-production.

People who join the Japan-side AI songwriting lessons need no music theory background and can start without playing an instrument. That makes the experiment friendly for beginners as well as for experienced writers who want to test a new tool.

What you might discover

Writers who try this often find that the two versions differ less in quality than in feeling. The hand-made song may carry a personal detail that no tool could guess, while the AI-assisted song may reach a finished arrangement in a fraction of the time. Neither result is a verdict. Both are information about your own taste, your schedule and the kind of music you want to make, and that information is what makes the next project easier to plan.

Common questions

Do we have to use AI at all? No. Version A is a complete song on its own, and some writers decide to keep their process entirely by hand.

Should both versions be released? They do not have to be. The experiment is for learning. If you release one, record in the credits how it was made.

If you would like to run this experiment with a songwriter in Japan, the Global Music Partnership window can start with one small co-written song, in English or Japanese. Send your goals, country and time zone to begin: global-music-partnership.jp.

FAQ

How long does the experiment take?

Two to four short sessions are enough for a verse and a chorus in each version.

Can a beginner try it?

Yes. The Japan-side AI songwriting lessons are open to people who do not read music and have no experience with instruments.

How should we credit the AI-assisted version?

Write a plain making-of note saying which stages used AI and which were done by hand, and agree credits with your co-writer in writing beforehand.